South Hebron Hills

Natanya G. and Michal Tz. (reports) Charles K. (trans.)
Seriously? Does this make us safer?

We decided to visit localities along Highway 317.  We drove to the Metzudat Yehuda checkpoint because we hadn’t been there in a while.  We were particularly interested to see what happens to the children from Imnazil who go through the checkpoint twice a day because their school is on the other side of the fence.  Everything was deserted because the schools in the Palestinian Authority are on strike.  No one knows for how long.  It depends on whether salaries will be paid.


Umm el Hir

So we drove to Umm el Hir to support their endless struggle against the wickedness and stupidity of all the Israeli institutions.

Eid showed us their main clay baking oven that had been vandalized again the day before yesterday – so often they’ve lost count.

For thirty years they’ve baked bread there for the small village.  Thirty years that they’ve been neighbors of the Carmel settlement. 

We were glad to see it operating again.  They’d brought dried dung, cleaned out the pit and laid a new fire.

Light smoke rises; Eid explains that sometimes, when there’s an east wind, the smell of the smoke from the dung reaches the tender nostrils of the Carmel settlers living in the new neighborhood, 100 meters away beyond the fence.  They can’t stand the smell so they extinguish the fire with water and vandalize the oven.

The village is subject to demolition orders; their case is in court.  So the settlers asked for demolition orders against the oven as well.  The judge tells them:  How can you demolish a structure that doesn’t exist?  Is a clay oven a structure?  Meanwhile, Eid says, “We need bread to eat.”  All the notables from all the authorities came to see what could be done.


Avi Biton, the regional brigade commander, deserves credit for honestly trying to solve the problem.  He suggested constructing a gas oven.  “Will you provide and pay for the gas?” the locals ask.  The oven has to remain hot; the goat dung is free.  The authorities say it’s complicated.







So Eid says, “Provide us with bread.  A truck brings bread to Carmel every day.  It can bring us bread also.  We’re neighbors, just beyond the fence.”  It turns out that’s also complicated.



The day before yesterday, the settlers vandalize the oven, the army even brought a tracker who discovered that the track led to the home of the nearest settler.  “So what happened?”, I asked.  Eid laughs and shrugs – “Nothing, as always.”


“You know,” he tells me, “Carmel’s veteran settlers are good neighbors; we get along with them.  They’ve been here since 1980; they behave well, and they’ve also helped us solve problems.  But the younger generation in the new neighborhood is terrible.”


We see a shed on a hill about one kilometer east of Umm el Hir with a seesaw and an Israeli flag.  It turns out the shed was erected about a year ago, and on Friday and Saturday the settlers go there to pray.  Their intent is obvious – to build an additional neighborhood to encircle Umm el Hir and eventually connect to Carmel.


Between the homes of the new neighborhood and this strange thing the residents of Umm el Hir planted a new olive grove, with the help of UNWRA, and fenced it well, hoping the settlers wouldn’t destroy it.


In general, whatever helps them live decently – solar electric panels, toilets, etc. – comes from the Village Group and donations from various organizations.  But solving the bread problem – that’s too complicated a project for the Israeli government.